Golden Corral vs Other Buffets: Cicis, Shady Maple and More Compared

Golden Corral is the biggest buffet chain in the United States, but it is not the only all-you-can-eat option. This guide compares it with Cicis Pizza, the budget pizza buffet, and Shady Maple Smorgasbord, the giant Pennsylvania Dutch buffet, so you can choose the right one for your budget and appetite.

Golden Corral buffet line with hot food

Quick Comparison

Golden CorralCicis PizzaShady Maple Smorgasbord
TypeAmerican comfort-food buffetPizza, pasta and salad buffetPennsylvania Dutch smorgasbord
LocationsAbout 330+ across the U.S.Nearly 300 in 30+ statesOne restaurant in East Earl, PA
Typical adult price$11.49 – $14.99 lunch, $16.99 – $19.99 dinnerAbout $9 – $12About $14 – $30 depending on meal and day
Kids pricingLower kids prices; 3 and under very low or freeLower kids prices; under 3 freeAge-based kids prices
DrinksExtra (about $2.50 – $3.50)ExtraIncluded
Extra feesSales taxSales tax6% PA tax plus 12% service fee
Open SundaysYesYesNo

Prices are typical ranges as of 2026 and vary by location and promotion. Always check with the restaurant before you go.

Golden Corral vs Cicis Pizza

Cicis is the cheapest all-you-can-eat option for most families. The regular adult buffet is usually about $9 to $12, and in 2026 Cicis has run frequent promotions such as a $5.99 adult buffet on Mondays and Tuesdays and a low first-visit price for new Cicis Rewards members. The trade-off is variety: Cicis is mostly pizza, pasta, salad and dessert pizza.

Golden Corral costs a few dollars more but offers far more choice, including carved sirloin, fried and grilled chicken, pot roast, a full salad bar, vegetables, breakfast on weekends and a large dessert bar. For a family with picky eaters who love pizza, Cicis wins on price. For mixed tastes, bigger appetites or anyone wanting a full meal with vegetables and protein, Golden Corral is the better value.

Golden Corral vs Shady Maple Smorgasbord

Shady Maple in East Earl, Pennsylvania is often called the largest buffet in the country, with roughly 200 feet of food. Its prices are higher, from about $14 for weekday breakfast to around $30 for premium dinner nights, and a 6% Pennsylvania sales tax plus a 12% service fee are added. Drinks are included and tipping is not expected because of the service fee. It is closed on Sundays.

Golden Corral is the everyday option: it is open seven days a week, has hundreds of locations and costs less per visit. Shady Maple is a destination trip, worth it if you are visiting Lancaster County and want regional dishes, carved prime rib and a huge dessert spread.

Which Buffet Is Best for Families?

Family needBest pickWhy
Lowest costCicisLowest adult price and frequent deals
Picky kids who love pizzaCicisPizza, pasta and dessert pizza
Mixed tastes and dietsGolden CorralMeats, vegetables, salads and desserts in one place
Weekend breakfastGolden CorralBreakfast buffet at most locations
Special day tripShady MapleHuge regional spread and theme nights
SeniorsGolden CorralComfort food, early hours and many locations

Cost for a Family of Four

BuffetEstimated total*
Cicis (2 adults, 2 kids)$30 – $45
Golden Corral weekday lunch$41 – $55
Golden Corral weekend dinner$55 – $70
Shady Maple weekday lunch$70 – $95 including service fee

*Rough estimates including drinks where they are extra, before sales tax. Promotions can lower these totals.

Our Verdict

For everyday value and variety, Golden Corral is the best all-round buffet for most families. Choose Cicis when the budget is tight and everyone is happy with pizza. Save Shady Maple for a special trip to Pennsylvania Dutch Country.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Golden Corral cheaper than Shady Maple?

Yes. Golden Corral weekday lunch is usually several dollars cheaper per adult, and Shady Maple adds a 12% service fee on top of tax.

Is Cicis cheaper than Golden Corral?

Usually yes. Cicis adult buffets typically cost a few dollars less, and its Monday and Tuesday deals can be cheaper still.

What is the biggest buffet chain in the U.S.?

Golden Corral is the largest buffet chain in the United States by number of restaurants.

Similar Posts